The most popular posts are in the sidebar now. I can’t say as though the list is particularly better now than it was a few days ago though….
When I first installed Popularity Contest the popularity was based completely on the number of comments that posts had (I have a grand total of about 3 trackbacks, so even though they’re calculated, they didn’t do much). This lead to some strange things. My number 2 most popular post was Finally I know, a post from a long time ago where I took a quiz to find out just exactly what kind of lesbian I am. The quiz told me that I am a tomboy. Go figure….
I’d totally forgotten about the post. Very few people stumble across this post through searches I’m quite sure, so it’s probably not really that popular, but it had a lot of comments, so it scored high and looked that way.
Fast forward to today. That post is now quite a ways down the list and won’t make the top 5 to show up in the sidbar. It’s not even close. (Note the funny thing here though is that by mentioning it and linking to it, at least a few people will undoubtedly click on the link and it’s popularity will climb up a little again
). Instead, the Why You Should Use Firefox post is #1. This posts popularity is bolstered by a high number of home page views (#2 is also a recent post bolstered by homepage views, btw). The post that should (and eventually will, I believe) be #1 is the current #3, Unknown Symbols or possibly #4, Gummi Bears. Both of those posts get a lot of views from searches. Despite permalinks being worth 5 times as much as homepage views when scores are calculated, recent posts with a few comments to bolster the scores still win out.
Given a few weeks it’ll even itself out though. Those really “popular” posts will drop off the homepage and receive relatively little attention while the posts that get lots of search hits will continue to rack up the points. Furthermore, since all the scores are relative, as time goes on and those latter posts get more and more points, the points that posts initially get from homepage visits won’t be worth enough to make them seem really popular. For now, I could always adjust the point values so it looks more like reality, but I’m not going to. Probably the best reason for this is that I think the way it scores right now looks fair in the long run, and if I change something there’s a pretty good chance that I’ll forget to put it back later. Besides, it’s fun to watch in the mean time…
No Tags
Popularity: 2% [?]